Reviewed by Linda C. Brinson
VERDICTS OF THE NEUSE. By Jesse Pittman. Pittman Publishing. 349 pages. $19.99, soft cover; $24.99, hard cover.
Jesse Pittman knows what he’s writing about. He is retired from the Craven County, NC, sheriff’s department after serving 28 years in a variety of positions. The county courthouse and the administration building in historic New Bern, the county seat, are places he knows well. He obviously understands their atmosphere and behind-the-scenes activities as well as what the general public usually sees.
He has put his knowledge to good use in Verdicts of the Neuse, a legal suspense/mystery novel he says is the beginning of a mystery series starring Ben Mercer, a captain in the sheriff’s department.
There is much to like about Pittman’s debut book. As it opens, we meet Ben Mercer, a 28-year veteran of the sheriff’s department, starting a day that could be any day, with meetings under way in the administration building. Suddenly gunfire erupts, and the day becomes far from routine.
A county commissioner lies dead on the floor in the administration building. Everyone springs into action, but before they can sort out what’s going on, another shot leaves a judge severely wounded in the courthouse across the street.
Ben Mercer finds himself face to face with the gunman, who, to his surprise, knows who he is.
Mercer tries to talk the gunman, now wounded, into giving himself up, but suddenly another gunman appears and shoots the man dead.
Before all the shooting is done, a young deputy is also injured.
The first shooter said enough that Mercer realizes he was the son of Thomas Vale, a man convicted of murder when Mercer was a beginning deputy nearly three decades ago. Vale had been found guilty in the death of Emily Dawson, a young county employee.
Despite his conviction, Vale had steadfastly maintained his innocence for the rest of his life.
The county commissioner Vale’s son had just killed had been the district attorney at the time of Vale’s trial. The judge Vale’s son had shot had presided.
Mercer remembers something he’d long forgotten: After the verdict, Thomas Vale had tried to give him an envelope, saying it contained proof of his innocence. A lowly rookie, Mercer quickly allowed the district attorney to take the envelope from him.
Thus begins a quest not only to understand the current shootings and find the second gunman, but also to look back at the conviction of Thomas Vale.
Pittman weaves a mystery with plenty of twists and turns. He does a good job of developing Ben Mercer and some of the other characters. Mercer is a principled lawman who realizes that the truth can be elusive, even when a verdict has been reached, and that finding the truth is vitally important.
There are some problems with the novel, however.
Pittman’s writing style almost kept me from reading his book. Most of the story is told in single sentences, not paragraphs, resulting in an odd and, for me, off-putting appearance. When reading, it sometimes seems that Pittman is emphasizing various points a bit too much.
As the novel’s title suggests, Pittman has the Neuse River to play a role in his story, writing about how the river flows on no matter what crimes the people who live along it may commit. The idea is a good one, but he borders on overdoing the theme.
All in all, though, I hope Pittman succeeds with his plans to write a series featuring Ben Mercer and the New Bern area. I was a little disappointed that this first book didn’t give us more of a feel for New Bern, a city that’s rich in history and atmosphere.
Let’s hope the books to come will show us more.
2 responses to “In search of the truth”
Interesting. I know Mr. Pittman.. If the genre is Crime/fiction how does he convey his story?
Are they based on true cases, solved or unsolved?
You would have to ask him that. His books are fiction, but only he would know how much he draws on real life for his stories. It would be interesting to know.